Harlem soul food guide: Sylvia’s, Red Rooster and Amy Ruth’s

Harlem soul food in one day: a 1962 landmark, a chef-driven restaurant on Lenox Avenue, and a small Southern kitchen named for a grandmother.

Harlem has several kinds of soul food restaurant, and they sit within a short walk of each other. One opened in 1962 and received a 2024 James Beard Foundation America’s Classics Award, according to its site. One is a modern restaurant by a chef who built a global career. One is a small kitchen named for a grandmother. This guide compares three of them and adds a nearby stop for a different Harlem tradition: pizza from 1933. Hours below come from official sites where we could read them.

Sylvia’s Restaurant

Sylvia Woods opened Sylvia’s on Lenox Avenue in 1962, according to the restaurant’s website. The site describes it as Harlem’s home for soul food and family and says it has served the community for more than 60 years. It lists a 2024 James Beard Foundation America’s Classics Award.

The address is 328 Malcolm X Boulevard, the avenue’s current name. The site lists hours of 11 AM to 10 PM Wednesday to Saturday and 11 AM to 8 PM Sunday to Tuesday. The menu highlights include fried chicken, chicken and waffles, smothered chicken, smothered turkey wings, collard greens, cornbread, macaroni and cheese, candied yams, black-eyed peas, barbecue short ribs and sweet potato pie. The page we read did not mention a gospel brunch, so call (212) 996-0660 to ask. Read more in our Sylvia’s guide.

Red Rooster Harlem

Red Rooster is at 310 Lenox Avenue. Marcus Samuelsson is the chef behind it and co-created it with Andrew Chapman, says the restaurant’s site. One staff biography on the site says Red Rooster Harlem and Ginny’s Supperclub opened in 2010. Samuelsson’s bio says he has won eight James Beard Foundation Awards.

The menu is broader than a traditional soul food list. Photo captions on the site name fried chicken, chicken and waffles, catfish over baked beans, shrimp and grits, grilled salmon, steak with chimichurri, pulled pork lettuce cups and a cheeseburger. The dining room is open Monday to Thursday from 12 PM to 9:30 PM, Friday from 12 PM to 10:30 PM, Saturday from 11 AM to 10:30 PM and Sunday from 10 AM to 9:30 PM. The bar keeps later hours. These come from the restaurant’s site, which may change.

Red Rooster’s site also names Ginny’s Supperclub as a sister venue that opened with it in 2010. It does not list Ginny’s address or hours, so look that up separately. Samuelsson also runs restaurants in Overtown, Miami and other cities, according to the site, which makes Red Rooster the Harlem anchor of a larger group.

Amy Ruth’s

Amy Ruth’s is at 113 West 116th Street. Sources disagree about when it opened. One listing says 1991, and others say 1998 or 1999, so we do not state a year. The restaurant is named for Amy Ruth Bass, the grandmother of founder Carl Redding, who is described as owner and chef and as someone who learned to cook alongside her. The menu is known for plates named for public figures, and one listing says a chicken plate carries President Barack Obama’s name. We have not confirmed current hours, menu or whether the dish names are still in use, so check before you go.

A different Harlem: Patsy’s in East Harlem

East Harlem was once called Italian Harlem. Wikipedia says Pasquale “Patsy” Lancieri opened Patsy’s Pizzeria there in 1933, and the original is at 2287 First Avenue at East 117th Street. The restaurant claims to have started selling pizza by the slice, which rests on its own account. It is a useful stop if you want to see how many immigrant traditions sit within a few blocks. See our pizza history guide.

Wikipedia adds a few facts about Patsy’s. Frank Brija, an Albanian from Kosovo, bought the pizzeria in 1991 and later trademarked the name and opened other locations. A legal fight with an unrelated restaurant called Patsy’s on West 56th Street began in 2009. And the restaurant’s facade was recreated as a film set in England in 2024. The East Harlem original remains the one to visit if you want the neighborhood context. Check its official site for current hours, which we could not confirm.

How to plan a Harlem food day

  • Lunch: Sylvia’s, from 11 AM, for a full plate.
  • Walk: Stroll Lenox Avenue. Red Rooster’s address on Lenox Avenue is only a block or so from Sylvia’s.
  • Dinner: Red Rooster, or save it for another visit.
  • Transit: The 2 and 3 trains stop at 125th Street. For other stops, use a transit map.
  • Another option: The Cecil is also in Harlem and has its own menu.
  • Parks: Central Park reaches the neighborhood’s southern edge at 110th Street.

What to order if it is your first time

Start with fried chicken and one smothered dish, then add sides. At Sylvia’s, share collard greens, macaroni and cheese and candied yams. At Red Rooster, ask what the kitchen is proud of that day. Finish with sweet potato pie where it is on the menu.

Practical tips

  • Plan for a meal, not a quick stop. Portions are generous.
  • Check dietary needs ahead. Southern food often relies on pork and butter.
  • Confirm hours, especially on holidays.
  • Walk between meals. Harlem rewards on-foot exploring.

Frequently asked questions

What is soul food?

It is Southern-rooted Black American cooking: fried chicken, greens, cornbread and sweet potato pie are classic examples, all of which appear on Sylvia’s menu.

Which restaurant should I try first?

For a classic, start with Sylvia’s. For a modern take, try Red Rooster.

Do I need a reservation?

Check each official site. Policies change, and we have not confirmed them.