Every old restaurant in New York has a founding story, and most of them are a little polished. This guide lists five Manhattan restaurants with long records, says where each claim is solid, and flags where historians disagree. They span a tavern whose building dates to 1719, a fine-dining name from 1837, and steakhouses and a pub that opened in the 1800s. Hours below come from official pages where we could read them, and everything else is marked.
Fraunces Tavern, 54 Pearl Street
The building was built in 1719 by Stephen DeLancey, according to Wikipedia. Samuel Fraunces bought it in 1762 and turned it into a tavern. Wikipedia says George Washington dined there in 1776 and bade farewell to his officers there on December 4, 1783. The building was nearly demolished in the early 1900s, then saved and restored, and it became a New York City landmark in 1965.
The tavern’s own website calls itself “Revolutionary Since 1762” and the oldest and most historic bar in the city. Treat the second claim as the tavern’s own. A museum on the upper floors was established in 1907 and focuses on the American Revolutionary era, with about 8,000 objects, says Wikipedia. The museum, bar and restaurant are all listed as operating. The tavern’s site gives (212) 968-1776 and no hours, so call or check the museum site before you go.
Delmonico’s, 56 Beaver Street
Delmonico’s started in 1827, when brothers Giovanni and Pietro Delmonico opened a shop at 23 William Street, says Wikipedia. The Beaver Street building opened in 1837 after the Great Fire. The restaurant is credited with several dishes, including Delmonico potatoes and Lobster Newberg, but Wikipedia says the Baked Alaska and Eggs Benedict stories are disputed, so we do not repeat them as fact.
The restaurant closed in 2020 during the pandemic and reopened on September 18, 2023, after a new lease. Its official site lists lunch Monday to Friday, 12 PM to 3 PM, and dinner Monday to Friday 5 PM to 10 PM, Saturday 4 PM to 10 PM, and Sunday 3 PM to 9 PM. The page is not dated, so confirm before you go.
Pete’s Tavern, 129 East 18th Street
Wikipedia calls Pete’s Tavern the oldest continuously operating restaurant and bar in New York City. The building was constructed in 1829 as the Portman Hotel, and the first official drinking establishment there dates to 1864. In 1899 Tom and John Healy bought it and renamed it Healy’s. It kept running during Prohibition while disguised as a flower shop, and Peter D’Belles bought it in 1926 and gave it the current name.
The same article notes that the tavern calls itself an official historical landmark, but it is neither a designated city landmark nor on the National Register. It lies within the Gramercy Park Historic District. There is also a local legend that O. Henry wrote “The Gift of the Magi” in a booth, which Wikipedia calls apocryphal. Hours are not listed on the tavern’s site, which points to Resy and phone 212-473-7676.
Old Homestead Steakhouse, 56 Ninth Avenue
Old Homestead opened in 1868, according to Wikipedia, in the Meatpacking District. Wikipedia calls it the oldest continuously operating steakhouse in the United States, predating Keens and Peter Luger. A cow statue in front became the restaurant’s symbol after a Texan patron promised to send a cow. Grandsons of Harry Sherry, who bought it in the 1940s, run it now. We did not find an official site for current hours. Third-party listings suggest dinner service and conflicting Monday hours, so call (212) 242-9040.
Keens Steakhouse, 72 West 36th Street
Albert Keen opened the chophouse around 1885 in Herald Square, says Wikipedia, and women were barred until 1905, when actress Lillie Langtry sued and won. The restaurant’s own site calls it the only survivor of the old Herald Square theatre district and says it received a James Beard Foundation America’s Classic Award in 2013. Keens is known for its mutton chop and for a clay pipe collection on the ceiling. Wikipedia reports more than 50,000 pipes according to the New York Times, while the official site says about 90,000, so numbers vary by source.
The official site lists hours of 11:45 AM to 10:30 PM Monday to Friday, 5 PM to 10:30 PM Saturday and 5 PM to 9:30 PM Sunday, with a closure on Christmas Day. Wikipedia reports that Keens was sold in November 2024 to Texas restaurateur Tilman Fertitta.
How to choose
- For history: Fraunces Tavern, with its museum.
- For a formal dinner: Delmonico’s.
- For a pub night: Pete’s Tavern.
- For steak: Old Homestead or Keens.
- On a budget: Check official menus first. These are not low-cost restaurants.
A note on claims
Old restaurants love superlatives. When a source calls a place the oldest, we say who is claiming it. Pete’s Tavern, Old Homestead and Fraunces Tavern each have a different claim to age, and they overlap in ways that depend on definitions, such as continuous operation or the building’s age. Use them as invitations, not rankings.
If you prefer something smaller
Century-old food shops can be easier to enjoy than formal restaurants. Try Nom Wah Tea Parlor for dim sum served since 1920, or Katz’s Delicatessen for a Lower East Side deli. See our guide to ordering at old-school counters.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the oldest restaurant in Manhattan?
It depends on the definition. Wikipedia calls Pete’s Tavern the oldest continuously operating restaurant and bar, and Old Homestead the oldest continuously operating steakhouse.
Do I need reservations?
Pete’s points to Resy. For the others, check the official site or call.
Are these places family friendly?
Policies vary. Check each venue before you bring children.