Manhattan pizza history guide: Lombardi’s, John’s and Joe’s

Manhattan’s oldest pizza names come with disputed dates and family feuds. Here is what the records say about Lombardi’s, John’s, Patsy’s and Joe’s.

Ask five New Yorkers where pizza began in America and you will get five answers. The records are messier than the legends. Lombardi’s says it was first, but later research points elsewhere. John’s of Bleecker Street may date to 1915, not 1929. Patsy’s in East Harlem started a family feud that produced a famous Brooklyn pizzeria. This guide walks through four Manhattan pizza names and what we can say about each, with the caveats attached.

Lombardi’s: the famous claim

Lombardi’s Pizza is at 32 Spring Street, at the corner of Mott Street in Nolita. According to Wikipedia, the traditional account says Gennaro Lombardi opened a grocery in 1897 and became a licensed pizzeria in 1905, with the tenor Enrico Caruso among its reported customers. The Pizza Hall of Fame has called it the first pizzeria in the United States, but later research found pizzerias that predate it by more than a decade.

A 2019 challenge suggests that records show Gennaro arrived in 1904 as a laborer, which would make him an employee rather than the founder. The same research points to Filippo Milone as the pizzeria’s opener. The original location closed in 1984, and the pizzeria reopened about a block away around 1994, says Wikipedia. During the early pandemic, the article reports, the owners gave up one of two leases and the building’s new owner destroyed the coal oven. We have not confirmed the current oven or menu, so check the official site.

John’s of Bleecker Street: the no-slice rule

John’s is at 278 Bleecker Street in Greenwich Village. Wikipedia reports that documents show Filippo Milone opened the pizzeria in 1915, though it was long believed to date from 1929 under John Sasso. Sasso took over in 1925, and in 1953 he sold it to relatives Augustine and Joe Vesce. The pizzeria serves whole pies, not slices, and uses a coal-fired brick oven that reaches 850 degrees Fahrenheit, according to the same article. Wikipedia adds that it accepted only cash until May 2016.

Note the name Filippo Milone again. Wikipedia credits him with both John’s and, in the 2019 research, the Spring Street pizzeria. That is a reminder that early Manhattan pizza history involved a small circle of people.

Patsy’s in East Harlem: slices and a feud

Patsy’s Pizzeria opened in 1933 in East Harlem, according to Wikipedia, when Pasquale “Patsy” Lancieri started it in what was then Italian Harlem. The restaurant claims to have started selling pizza by the slice, a claim that rests on its own account. Wikipedia says Lancieri reportedly learned his craft at Lombardi’s coal oven. The original location is at 2287 First Avenue at East 117th Street.

The family story has a twist. Lancieri’s nephew, Patsy Grimaldi, opened a Brooklyn pizzeria in 1990 and later renamed it Grimaldi’s, says Wikipedia. Frank Brija bought Patsy’s in 1991 and later opened other locations. We have not confirmed current hours at the East Harlem original, so check before you go.

Joe’s Pizza: the Village slice

Joe’s is the modern slice shop in this group. The shop says Joe Pozzuoli, from Naples, started it in 1975 at Bleecker and Carmine Streets and moved three doors down to 7 Carmine Street. It serves classic New York slices and only pizza, according to Wikipedia. Our Joe’s Pizza guide covers the details. Joe’s is not a coal-oven pie house. It is a counter for a hot slice, and that is the point.

Footnotes that make the stories fun

Wikipedia adds small details that show how much these shops mean to the city. Lombardi’s lost the title of America’s longest continually operating pizzeria to Papa’s Tomato Pies in Trenton, New Jersey, which opened in 1912. For anniversaries in 2005 and 2015 it offered whole pizzas at 5 cents, the price it says applied in 1905. John’s was ranked the tenth best pizzeria in the United States by TripAdvisor in 2015, and it only began taking credit cards in May 2016. Patsy’s East Harlem original appeared as a recreated set in England in 2024 for the film A Quiet Place: Day One, and in 2019 a Patsy’s waiter returned a lost cashier’s check of more than $400,000 to a customer.

Joe’s brief closure in 2005 and its screen appearances are well documented too. It shows up in Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Conan O’Brien learned to make pizza there in 2011, says Wikipedia. These details are entertaining, but remember the rule of thumb: a famous shop is not always the oldest, and the oldest is not always the best.

How to compare them

  • Slices: Joe’s sells them. John’s does not.
  • Ovens: John’s uses coal. Check Lombardi’s before you assume.
  • Age: Documents point to 1915 for John’s, 1933 for Patsy’s and 1975 for Joe’s. Lombardi’s dates are disputed.
  • Setting: Joe’s is a counter. The others are sit-down rooms.
  • Payments: Policies change. Ask before you order.

A pizza day in Manhattan

Start in Little Italy for context. Walk Mulberry Street and read our Little Italy food guide. Eat a pie at Lombardi’s, then take the train to Greenwich Village for a slice at Joe’s and a walk through Washington Square Park. Skip dessert until Ferrara or Veniero’s. Leave East Harlem for another day, since it is a separate trip north.

Frequently asked questions

Which was the first pizzeria in America?

Lombardi’s has long claimed it, but Wikipedia says later research found pizzerias that predate it by more than a decade.

Is John’s of Bleecker Street open?

Wikipedia lists it as a Bleecker Street pizzeria. Check its official site for current hours.

Where can I get a slice?

Joe’s sells slices. John’s sells whole pies only, according to Wikipedia.