The Italian population of Little Italy peaked at almost 10,000 people in 1910, according to Wikipedia. By the 2010 American Community Survey, the same source says, no residents of the neighborhood had been born in Italy. The streets still carry the name, and a few family businesses still carry the food. This guide separates the shops with real history from the ones that mostly sell the idea of Italy.
A neighborhood that shrank
Little Italy began around Mulberry Bend, south of Canal Street, in the old Five Points area. At its largest it stretched from Lafayette Street to the Bowery and from Kenmare Street to Worth Street, says Wikipedia. After World War II many Italian families moved to Brooklyn, Staten Island, Long Island, Westchester and New Jersey. Chinatown then grew north after the 1965 immigration law. Today Mulberry Street, the main corridor, runs only five blocks north of Canal Street.
In 2010, Little Italy and Chinatown were listed together as a historic district on the National Register of Historic Places, according to the same article. That fact is a good frame for a visit: this is one district with two food traditions, and the border is only a few blocks wide.
Di Palo’s Fine Foods: mozzarella and conversation
Start at Grand and Mott. CBS News reports that Savino Di Palo opened a cheese shop on Mott Street in 1910, and that his daughter Concetta opened a shop on the corner of Mott and Grand in 1925. That shop became Di Palo’s. His great-grandchildren Lou, Marie and Sal run it today, and the mozzarella is still made by hand daily. CBS also reports more than 75 pecorino cheeses. Read more in our Di Palo’s guide. Call the shop at (212) 226-1033 for hours.
Ferrara Bakery & Cafe: espresso and pastry
Across the street is Ferrara’s at 195 Grand Street. Antonio Ferrara founded it in 1892, and the business describes itself as America’s first espresso bar, a claim Wikipedia repeats as the shop’s own. What you can verify is that the family still runs it at its original address. Sit with an espresso and look at the pastry case. Details are in our Ferrara guide.
Lombardi’s Pizza: a famous name with a messy history
Lombardi’s at 32 Spring Street in Nolita is often called the first pizzeria in the United States. Wikipedia explains that the Pizza Hall of Fame has said so, but later research found pizzerias that predate it by more than a decade. The traditional account says Gennaro Lombardi opened a grocery in 1897 and began selling pizza in 1905. A 2019 challenge says records suggest Filippo Milone opened the pizzeria. Wikipedia also reports the original location closed in 1984 and the pizzeria reopened about a block away around 1994. The same article says that during the early pandemic the owners gave up one of two leases and the building owner destroyed a coal oven. Check the official site for what is baking today. Our Manhattan pizza history guide compares Lombardi’s with other early pizzerias.
The Feast of San Gennaro
The feast began in 1926 as a one-day religious commemoration by immigrants from Naples honoring their patron saint, San Gennaro, says Wikipedia. It is now an 11-day street fair on Mulberry Street. We do not list 2026 or 2027 dates here because we have not found a dated official source. Check the organizers’ site before you plan around it.
The Feast of the Seven Fishes
Wikipedia says the Christmas Eve tradition of seven fish dishes is thought to have started in Little Italy in the late 1800s. If you are visiting in December, it is a good excuse to look for seafood on a menu.
How to eat smart on Mulberry Street
- Look for proof of age. A restaurant that cites a founding year, a family name and a source is better than one with a hawker at the door.
- Eat at counters. Cheese shops, bakeries and cafes are where the old families still work.
- Skip the tourist menu board. Wikipedia noted about 50 restaurants and cafes aimed at tourists as of 2004. Be selective.
- Combine with Chinatown. Nom Wah Tea Parlor on Doyers Street is a short walk. See our Nom Wah guide.
- Check hours. Third-party listings for these shops disagree, so confirm each before you go.
A two-hour route
Start at Canal Street and walk north on Mulberry. Stop for cheese at Grand and Mott, then cross to Ferrara for coffee. Continue north to Spring Street for a look at Lombardi’s. If you want a second meal, return south and walk to Doyers Street for dim sum. That gives you cheese, pastry, pizza history and Chinatown in a compact loop.
Getting there
The Canal Street station serves the 6, J, N, Q, R, W and Z trains. From there, walk east to Mulberry Street, which is a few minutes on foot.
Frequently asked questions
Is Little Italy still Italian?
Culturally it keeps Italian-American businesses and festivals, but the residential population is much smaller than in 1910, according to Wikipedia.
Is Lombardi’s really the first pizzeria in America?
That is the traditional claim. Wikipedia says later research found earlier pizzerias, so the claim is disputed.
Do I need a reservation for Di Palo’s or Ferrara?
Di Palo’s is a shop, so there is nothing to book. For Ferrara and Lombardi’s, check the official site for current policies.