A bagel has a hole. A bialy has a dent. A knish has a filling wrapped inside. Those three sentences are most of what you need, but the stories behind them explain why Manhattan’s Lower East Side and Upper West Side still carry the shops that serve them. This guide uses shop websites and Wikipedia to separate the three foods and point you to a place for each.
The bialy: a roll from Bialystok
Kossar’s says a bialy is a bread that Jewish immigrants from Bialystok, Poland, brought to the Lower East Side. The name is short for the Yiddish “Bialystoker kuchen,” meaning little bread from Bialystok. The bakery says its bialys are baked in a brick oven, while its bagels are kettle-boiled.
That difference is the key. A bagel is boiled and then baked. A bialy, as Kossar’s describes it, is baked without the kettle-boiling step. It has a flat center instead of a hole.
Kossar’s says it is the oldest operating bialy bakery in the United States. The history page says Isadore Mirsky and Morris Kossar started Mirsky and Kossar’s Bakery at 22 Ridge Street in 1936, and that an explosion destroyed the Clinton Street store on February 20, 1958, during a long strike. The bakery reopened at 367 Grand Street in 1960. The claim of being oldest is the bakery’s own. Our Kossar’s guide has the practical details.
The knish: a filled pastry
A knish is a baked dough pocket around a filling, often potato. Yonah Schimmel Knish Bakery at 137 East Houston Street says it has operated since 1910. Wikipedia says Yonah Schimmel, an immigrant from Galicia, started from a pushcart and later rented a store on Allen Street, and that by 1916 he ran several knish bakeries. The store moved to its current location in the 1930s when Houston Street was widened for the subway.
On the bakery’s site, the classic potato knish uses Uncle Yonah’s original recipe and is vegan. Other flavors include mushroom and mixed veggie, and Wikipedia adds kasha and sweet cheese knishes. The bakery says it is certified kosher. See our Yonah Schimmel guide.
Who ran the knish shop
Wikipedia traces the bakery’s family line. Josef Berger, who partnered with Yonah Schimmel around 1915, eventually took over the East Houston Street store and kept the name. He died in 1931, and his son Arthur ran the bakery until 1974, followed by Arthur’s widow Lillian until about 1990. The page says the business is now run by Yonah’s great-nephew, Alex Wolfman. The shop has also been an art subject: a portrait by Hedy Pagremanski belongs to the permanent collection of the Museum of the City of New York, and Irish painter Harry Kernoff painted it during a 1939 trip. It appears in Woody Allen’s 2009 film Whatever Works, says Wikipedia.
The bagel: boiled, then baked
The bagel is the one most visitors know, so a short word on where to buy it. Zabar’s lists bagels among its signature foods, alongside smoked fish, cheese, rugelach and babka, and it is at 2245 Broadway. The store’s banner says “since 1934.” Kossar’s also makes bagels, which the bakery says are kettle-boiled. Wikipedia notes that Zabar’s is not kosher-certified but sells some kosher products. For a deeper look at smoked fish with your bagel, see our Upper West Side appetizing guide.
Why the Lower East Side kept these foods alive
The neighborhood was a first stop for many Jewish immigrants, and pushcarts and small bakeries were a way to earn a living with a family recipe. Yonah Schimmel’s beginnings with a pushcart and Kossar’s founding by two partners in 1936 both fit that pattern. Both bakeries also show how fragile that world was. Kossar’s reopened in 1960 after the 1958 explosion, and Yonah Schimmel moved when Houston Street was widened. Today they stand as working shops, not museums. Eat there, and you support the businesses that kept the foods alive.
Quick comparison
- Bagel: Ring-shaped, kettle-boiled, then baked. Eat with cream cheese or fish.
- Bialy: Flat roll with a center dent, baked, not boiled. Eat fresh and warm.
- Knish: Filled pastry, baked. Eat as a snack or small meal.
A short tasting plan
Begin on the Lower East Side with a bialy at Kossar’s on Grand Street. Walk to East Houston Street for a potato knish at Yonah Schimmel. Both shops are close enough to walk, and you can stop at Economy Candy for dessert. If you want a bagel, take the subway uptown to Zabar’s on another day, or order one at Kossar’s.
Practical tips
- Hours: Yonah Schimmel lists 10:30 AM to 6 PM daily. Kossar’s hours vary by listing, so check its site. Zabar’s lists store and cafe hours on its Broadway store page.
- Eat fresh: Bialys and knishes are best hot. Bagels travel better.
- Shipping: Kossar’s and Yonah Schimmel both say they ship nationwide through Goldbelly.
- Allergies: Ask about ingredients. Kosher certification does not mean allergen-free.
- Crowds: Weekend mornings are busiest.
Frequently asked questions
Is a bialy a bagel without a hole?
Close, but the difference is also in how it is made. Kossar’s says bialys are baked and bagels are kettle-boiled.
Are knishes vegetarian?
The potato knish at Yonah Schimmel is vegan, according to its site. Other flavors vary, so ask.
Which should I try first?
If you have had a bagel before, try a bialy. If you want something filling, try a knish.