How the loss of Penn Station saved New York’s landmarks

The 1963 demolition of the original Pennsylvania Station led to the 1965 Landmarks Law. Here is the story, and the landmarks you can visit because of it.

In October 1963, crews began to tear down one of the grandest buildings in New York. The original Pennsylvania Station had opened in 1910 as a gateway to the city, with a glass-roofed concourse and rows of stone columns. Within three years it was gone. The public anger that followed changed the law, and it is the reason you can still walk through Grand Central Terminal today.

What Penn Station was

According to Wikipedia, the station was declared complete on August 29, 1910, and fully opened on November 27, 1910. McKim, Mead & White designed it. Charles Follen McKim made the overall plan, and William Symmes Richardson finished the design after McKim’s health declined.

The numbers explain why people remember it. The station covered about eight acres. The glass roof over the main concourse measured 210 by 340 feet. The main waiting room was just over 314 feet long. About 650 steel columns held up the building, and the station served 21 tracks and 11 platforms.

The demolition

Demolition of the above-ground building began on October 28, 1963, and was finished in 1966. A new Madison Square Garden was built above the rebuilt underground concourses. The City Planning Department had voted in January 1963 to let the project go ahead, despite public opposition.

Architects and writers protested. One picket slogan was Don’t Amputate, Renovate. The critic Vincent Scully later contrasted entering the city through the old station with the experience of passing through the new one, and Ada Louise Huxtable wrote in The New York Times in 1963 that the city could no longer even maintain a building of that quality.

The law that followed

The city had a Landmarks Preservation Commission before Penn Station fell. According to Wikipedia, Mayor Robert F. Wagner Jr. formed it on April 21, 1962, but it had little power. The demolition proved the point.

The Landmarks Law passed the City Council on April 7, 1965, and Wagner signed it on April 20, 1965. The commission held its first public hearing that September. In October 1965 it designated its first twenty landmarks, and in November it created its first historic district, Brooklyn Heights. As of May 1, 2024, the commission reported more than 37,900 landmark properties, most of them in about 150 historic districts. That includes 1,460 individual landmarks, 121 interior landmarks and 12 scenic landmarks.

Grand Central and the test case

The next big test came in 1968, when the Penn Central company proposed demolishing or building over Grand Central Terminal. The commission preserved the terminal. Penn Central challenged the decision, and in 1978 the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the Landmarks Law in Penn Central Transportation Co. v. New York City. Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis was among the supporters of the effort to save the terminal.

You can see the result in person. Grand Central Terminal is open to the public, and our guide to Grand Central tours covers ways to see more of it.

Landmarks you can visit because of the law

The law covers buildings, interiors and whole districts. These places in our guide are all protected:

  • Trinity Church and St. Paul’s Chapel. Both were designated New York City landmarks on August 16, 1966, in the early years of the law.
  • Museum at Eldridge Street. The synagogue became a city landmark in 1980 and a National Historic Landmark in 1996.
  • Fraunces Tavern, designated by the city in 1965, with its surrounding block now a historic district.
  • Hamilton Grange, a New York City landmark since 1967.

The law also protects interiors, which is why places like Radio City Music Hall (interior landmark in March 1978) and the lobby of the Fuller Building (landmarked in 1986) have legal protection. For more, see our article on Art Deco lobbies in New York.

A short timeline

  • 1910: Penn Station is declared complete on August 29. The Long Island Rail Road starts using it on September 8, and the rest opens on November 27.
  • April 21, 1962: Mayor Wagner forms the Landmarks Preservation Commission.
  • January 1963: City Planning votes to allow demolition.
  • October 28, 1963: Demolition of the head house begins.
  • April 1965: The Landmarks Law is passed and signed.
  • 1966: Demolition is finished.
  • 1968: Penn Central proposes to demolish or build over Grand Central.
  • 1978: The Supreme Court upholds the law in the Grand Central case.

The order of events matters. The commission existed, but only the 1965 law gave it real power. That is why preservationists still point to Penn Station as a turning point, not just a loss.

What to know before you go

The old Penn Station is gone, but you can still stand on the site. Today’s station lies beneath Madison Square Garden, which was built over the rebuilt underground concourses. The best way to understand what was lost is to compare it with Grand Central, which still has a large public concourse of the kind the old station offered.

A good half-day plan: start at Grand Central, walk down to the Empire State Building, and finish at the New York Public Library, covered in our NYPL listing.

Frequently asked questions

When was the original Penn Station demolished?

Demolition of the above-ground building began on October 28, 1963, and ended in 1966.

What law did the demolition inspire?

The New York City Landmarks Law, passed on April 7, 1965 and signed on April 20, 1965.

Did the law save Grand Central?

Yes. The Landmarks Preservation Commission protected it, and the Supreme Court upheld the law in 1978.