Historic NYC churches you can visit, from 1766 to 1930

Eight historic churches and sanctuaries in Manhattan, each with a specific reason to step inside, from a 1766 chapel to a 1930 tower with a 74-bell carillon.

New York’s churches are some of its best free history lessons. They hold the city’s oldest surviving building, a cathedral still under construction, and a synagogue that waited decades for repair. Most are active places of worship, so visiting hours change around services. Check each official site before you go. Here are eight to put on a list, in rough order of age.

St. Paul’s Chapel (1766)

Wikipedia calls it the oldest surviving church building in Manhattan. It was finished in 1766 and the spire was added in 1794 to 1796. George Washington worshipped here on his inauguration day in 1789. After 9/11 it served as a place of rest for recovery workers for nine months. See our full guide to St. Paul’s Chapel.

St. Mark’s Church in-the-Bowery (1799)

Peter Stuyvesant built a family chapel on this East Village site by 1660, and he was buried in a vault beneath it after his death in 1672. The current fieldstone Georgian church was consecrated on May 9, 1799. Wikipedia describes the site as the city’s oldest site of continuous religious practice. A fire on July 27, 1978, nearly destroyed the church, and the restoration finished in 1986. The church also hosts the Poetry Project, founded in 1966. The address is 131 East 10th Street at Second Avenue.

Grace Church (1846)

James Renwick Jr. was 25 when he won the commission for this French Gothic Revival church at 800 to 804 Broadway, at East 10th Street. The sanctuary was consecrated in 1846. It is a National Historic Landmark, designated in 1977. Renwick later designed the marble spire that replaced the original wooden one.

Trinity Church (1846)

The third building on the site was designed by Richard Upjohn in the Gothic Revival style and consecrated on May 1, 1846. According to Wikipedia, it was the tallest building in the United States until 1869. Its churchyard includes the grave of Alexander Hamilton. Read more in our Trinity Church guide.

St. Patrick’s Cathedral (1879)

The cornerstone was laid in August 1858, work paused during the Civil War, and the cathedral was dedicated on May 25, 1879. The spires, finished in 1888, rise 329.5 feet. It seats about 2,400 people, and the rose window is 26 feet across. A restoration from 2012 to 2015 cost $177 million, according to Wikipedia. The address is 631 Fifth Avenue, across from Rockefeller Center. Pair it with Top of the Rock.

Eldridge Street Synagogue (1887)

The Museum at Eldridge Street occupies a synagogue dedicated on September 4, 1887. The sanctuary was sealed by 1954 and restored in a project that was rededicated on December 2, 2007. It is a museum now, so ticket and tour details apply. See the Museum at Eldridge Street guide.

Cathedral of St. John the Divine (begun 1892)

The cornerstone was laid on December 27, 1892. The building is 601 feet long and still unfinished. Wikipedia describes it as the largest church in North America. The cathedral opens its Great Bronze Doors only on special occasions. See our Cathedral of St. John the Divine guide.

Riverside Church (1930)

John D. Rockefeller Jr. funded much of this Neo-Gothic church, spending $10.5 million on land and construction. The first service was held on October 5, 1930. The tower is 392 feet tall, and the carillon has 74 bells and is dedicated to Laura Spelman Rockefeller. Designers Henry C. Pelton and Allen & Collens drew partly on Chartres Cathedral. The address is 490 Riverside Drive, a short walk from Grant’s Tomb.

If you only have time for two

Choose by what you want to see. For the oldest building, go to St. Paul’s Chapel, finished in 1766. For scale, go to the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, where the nave alone is 248 feet long and 146 feet wide. For a story about people instead of stone, pick the Museum at Eldridge Street, where immigrants built a grand synagogue in 1887 and then watched it decline. For a view from above, Riverside Church has a 392-foot tower, but check the official site to see whether tower access is offered when you visit.

If you like Gothic Revival design, compare three of them in a single day: Grace Church (1846), Trinity Church (1846) and St. Patrick’s Cathedral (1879). The first two were consecrated in the same year, designed by two different architects, Renwick and Upjohn, and the comparison is instructive.

How to plan a visit

  • Group by area. Downtown: St. Paul’s and Trinity. East Village: St. Mark’s and Grace. Midtown: St. Patrick’s. Morningside Heights: St. John the Divine and Riverside. Lower East Side: Eldridge Street.
  • Check services. All of these are active places of worship, and tours, concerts and services can limit access. Always check the official page that morning.
  • Dress and behavior. Keep voices low and respect services. Ask staff before photographing inside.
  • Cost. Some sites charge admission, some do not, and some run both a free prayer visit and a paid sightseeing tour. We list no prices here, so check each site.

A simple one-day route

Start early at St. Paul’s and Trinity, then ride north. Spend the middle of the day at Grace Church and St. Mark’s, both near East 10th Street. Finish in Morningside Heights with the cathedral and Riverside Church. Together they span from 1766 to 1930. The city’s landmark law, which came out of the loss of Penn Station, helped protect many of them. Read the story in How the loss of Penn Station saved New York’s landmarks.

Frequently asked questions

Which is the oldest church building in Manhattan?

Wikipedia calls St. Paul’s Chapel, finished in 1766, the oldest surviving church building in Manhattan.

Are historic churches in New York free to visit?

It depends. Some are free, some charge for tours, and some are museums. Check each official site.

Can I visit during a service?

Access during services can be limited. Confirm on the church’s calendar.