How to order at old-school NYC food counters

Tickets at Katz’s, numbered lines at fish counters, plates that come when they are ready: a practical guide to ordering at Manhattan’s classic food shops.

Classic New York food shops run on habits that nobody explains. A paper ticket at the door. A line that is not quite a line. A server who asks what you want before you have looked. First-time visitors sometimes freeze and lose their turn. This guide covers how several well-known Manhattan counters work, so you can order calmly and get the food you came for. Where we could not confirm a policy, we say so.

Katz’s: the ticket system

At Katz’s Delicatessen, 205 East Houston Street, a door attendant hands you a numbered ticket, according to Wikipedia. Staff at each food station record what you buy and keep a running total. At the end, a cashier collects your ticket and you pay. If you lose it, Wikipedia reports a $50 surcharge, which is meant to discourage patrons from swapping in a smaller ticket. Hold the ticket carefully and do not hand it over until you are ready to pay.

The deli is not kosher, says Wikipedia. It serves about 15,000 pounds of pastrami a week, according to the same source. For a fuller guide, see our Katz’s Delicatessen page.

Zabar’s and Barney Greengrass: fish counters

At a smoked fish counter, you order by weight and by type. Zabar’s lists hand-sliced smoked fish including Nova. Barney Greengrass lists nova, whitefish salad and caviar among its featured goods. Decide what you want while you wait, and ask for a taste if you are unsure. Staff may ask how thick you want it sliced. Ask how long it keeps if you are carrying it home.

Zabar’s has a separate cafe entrance, according to our search of its store page, so look for the door that matches your plan. Barney Greengrass has a store and a restaurant with different hours: the store opens at 8 AM and the restaurant at 8:30 AM, according to its site. See the Upper West Side appetizing guide for more.

Di Palo’s: let the counter talk

CBS News describes Di Palo’s in Little Italy as a place where staff explain where each product comes from and regulars are happy to wait. Don’t treat that as a delay. Ask what is freshest, ask for a recommendation, and be ready to change your order. The mozzarella is made by hand daily, according to CBS, so ask what has just come out. Call (212) 226-1033 if you need hours.

Nom Wah: plates arrive when ready

Dim sum at Nom Wah is made to order. Wikipedia says Wilson Tang moved the restaurant from metal carts to a made-to-order menu after taking over in 2010. That means no cart to flag down. You order from a menu, and plates arrive as they are done. Order three or four at first and add more. The restaurant’s site says the menu marks gluten-free, vegetarian and vegan items. See our Nom Wah guide.

Joe’s Pizza: the slice routine

At Joe’s on Carmine Street, you order at the counter and eat your slice on the sidewalk. Time Out reports no indoor seating. Payment options change, so ask, since some third-party listings say cash only. Our Joe’s Pizza guide has more detail.

Russ & Daughters and Economy Candy: buying by weight

Russ & Daughters at 179 East Houston Street is an appetizing store, according to Wikipedia, so you buy fish and spreads at the counter much as you would at Zabar’s. Joel Russ kept the store open seven days a week, says the same article. Check the official site for current hours. At Economy Candy on Rivington Street, the website lists candy by the pound, and the product list runs from licorice to halvah. Take a basket, fill it, and ask staff if you cannot find something. The store’s site does not list hours, so call (212) 254-1531 before a visit.

Bakeries: Veniero’s and Ferrara

Italian bakeries often have both a counter for takeout and tables for sitting. Veniero’s on East 11th Street and Ferrara on Grand Street both have rooms where you can sit with coffee and pastry, according to Wikipedia’s description of Veniero’s back room and sources on Ferrara. Look at the case first, then tell the server what you want. Confirm hours before a late visit, since listings disagree.

Five rules that work almost everywhere

  • Know your order before you reach the front. The line moves fast.
  • Be specific. Say the item, the size and whether you want it here or to go.
  • Watch the room. Notice whether people take a ticket, take a number or walk to the counter.
  • Ask when unsure. Staff in these shops are used to questions, and the good ones like to explain.
  • Check payment and hours online. We could not confirm cash or card policies for several of the shops above.

What to bring

  • A card and a small amount of cash as a backup.
  • A plan for where to eat. Many counters have limited seating.
  • A small cooler bag if you are buying fish or cheese to carry.
  • Patience for lines on weekends.

When to go

Weekday mornings and mid-afternoons are generally calmer than weekend lunch. Katz’s, Zabar’s and Joe’s draw crowds at peak times. Several shops, including Yonah Schimmel and Barney Greengrass, close in the late afternoon according to their sites, so plan earlier visits.

Frequently asked questions

Do I tip at a counter?

Customs vary. If you are unsure, check the shop’s website or ask staff.

Can I split a ticket at Katz’s?

Wikipedia says a cashier collects tickets when several people’s orders are combined. Ask at the register.

Is it rude to ask for a taste?

At fish and cheese counters it is common. Ask politely, and accept the answer.