New York has a word for the shops that sell smoked fish, cream cheese and spreads: appetizing. It is different from a deli, where you buy meat. Two stores on the Upper West Side show how the tradition works in practice. Zabar’s is a big, busy food emporium on Broadway, and Barney Greengrass is a smaller smoked-fish counter and daytime dining room on Amsterdam Avenue. Visit both in one morning and you will understand the city’s breakfast table.
Appetizing and deli: the difference
Wikipedia describes Russ & Daughters on the Lower East Side as an appetizing store, a shop built around smoked and cured fish and the spreads that go with bagels. A deli, such as the one at Katz’s, centers on meats like pastrami and corned beef. At Zabar’s and Barney Greengrass the lines blur. Both sell fish, bread and spreads, and Barney Greengrass also serves a restaurant menu with eggs and sandwiches.
Zabar’s: the big store at 80th Street
Zabar’s is at 2245 Broadway. Its website says “since 1934,” and Wikipedia says Louis Zabar and his wife Lillian began the business, with a Broadway store opening in 1941. Wikipedia also reports that in the late 1960s Zabar’s imported Wigomat drip coffee makers and was the first U.S. shop to sell them, and that the shop is known for bagels, smoked fish, olives and cheeses.
The website highlights hand-sliced smoked fish including Nova, artisanal cheeses, rugelach, babka, bagels, deli meats and its own coffee blends. A cafe with its own entrance sits beside the shop. The official Broadway store page lists store hours of 8 AM to 7:30 PM Monday to Saturday and 9 AM to 6 PM Sunday, and cafe hours of 8 AM to 6 PM Monday to Saturday and 9 AM to 6 PM Sunday. Confirm those before you travel. Zabar’s is not kosher-certified, according to Wikipedia, though it sells some kosher products.
See the Zabar’s guide for a short list of what to buy.
Barney Greengrass: the Sturgeon King
Barney Greengrass is at 541 Amsterdam Avenue, between 86th and 87th Streets. Wikipedia says Barney Greengrass opened a restaurant in 1908 at West 113th Street and St. Nicholas Avenue in Harlem and moved to the current site in 1929. In 1938 James J. Frawley gave Greengrass the nickname Sturgeon King. The shop specializes in smoked sturgeon, nova and whitefish.
Per the official site, the store is open Tuesday to Sunday, 8 AM to 5 PM. The restaurant is open Tuesday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 4 PM, and Saturday and Sunday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM. The shop’s site lists nova, plain cream cheese, Osetra caviar, pastrami, whitefish salad, blintzes and mini black-and-white cookies as featured products. Wikipedia notes a 2006 James Beard Foundation award and a place on the Financial Times 2021 list of the world’s 50 greatest food stores. Our Barney Greengrass guide has more.
Why these two shops became landmarks
Both stores have lasted because families kept running them. Wikipedia says brothers Saul and Stanley Zabar partnered in the business from 1960, that a move and expansion in the 1970s made it one of Manhattan’s largest supermarkets, and that a 1995 New York Times obituary reported about 35,000 weekly customers. Lori Zabar, a granddaughter, published a family history with recipes in 2022. The store appears in You’ve Got Mail (1998), according to Wikipedia, and on television in Seinfeld.
At Barney Greengrass, the founder’s son Marvin, known as Moe, and Moe’s wife Shirley ran the shop after the founder, and Moe’s son Gary took over in 2001, says Wikipedia. Anthony Bourdain’s praise for the chopped liver, quoted in the same article, adds to the shop’s reputation. Their longevity is why these shops feel less like businesses and more like neighborhood institutions.
How to shop for smoked fish
- Taste first. Ask for a small piece if the counter allows it.
- Order by weight. Fish is sold by weight. Ask the counter what quantity fits your group.
- Ask about slicing. Hand-sliced fish is a selling point at Zabar’s.
- Ask how long it keeps. Smoked fish is perishable. Plan to eat it within the time the staff gives you.
- Pair it correctly. A bagel, cream cheese and a slice of fish is the standard pairing.
A morning route
Start at Zabar’s when it opens for coffee at the cafe and a look around. Walk north along Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue to Barney Greengrass, about six blocks, for a sit-down meal before the lunch rush. After that, walk west to Riverside Park, or cross to Central Park for a picnic. If you want a museum afterward, the American Museum of Natural History is within walking distance.
Practical tips
- Transit: The 1 train serves both stops. Zabar’s is near the 79th Street station, and Barney Greengrass is a short walk from 86th Street.
- Crowds: Weekend mornings are busiest at both.
- Cash and cards: Check each official site for payment options.
- Holidays: Hours change. Barney Greengrass posted a special Monday opening for one holiday, so check before you travel.
- Gifts: Zabar’s lists gift collections and Barney Greengrass lists edible gifts on their sites.
Frequently asked questions
What is appetizing?
It describes shops that sell smoked fish, spreads and dairy-style foods. A deli sells meat.
Which is better, Zabar’s or Barney Greengrass?
They are different. Zabar’s is a large store with many categories. Barney Greengrass is a smaller counter and dining room focused on fish. Visit both if you can.
Can I eat at Zabar’s?
The official site lists a cafe. Check the official site for current service.