NYC parks built on landfills, airfields and forts

Some of the city’s best open space was once something else: a trash mountain, a runway, a harbor fort. Here is the story behind each, and how to visit.

New York City never had much spare land, so it reused what it had. Several of its best open spaces began as places no one wanted to visit: a landfill piled with household trash, an airfield nobody flew from, a harbor fort closed to the public. Over decades, planners, scientists and volunteers turned them into parks. Knowing the history makes each visit richer, and it explains why the ground sometimes looks odd, with hills in places where none should be.

Freshkills Park, Staten Island

The largest example. According to Wikipedia, Fresh Kills Landfill received the city’s municipal waste from 1948 through 2001. After the September 11 attacks it reopened briefly so that debris from the World Trade Center could be examined, and that material was buried in the West Mound. The site then closed for good.

The park plan covers about 2,200 acres. James Corner Field Operations won a design competition in 2003, and construction began in October 2008. Wikipedia lists Schmul Park (2012), Owl Hollow Fields (2013), the New Springville Greenway (2015) and the first 21 acres of North Park (October 15, 2023) as open. The park’s official site says the interior opens only during scheduled programs, so check its calendar. Read the Freshkills Park guide.

Shirley Chisholm State Park, Brooklyn

This 407-acre park in Spring Creek sits on the former Pennsylvania Avenue and Fountain Avenue landfills. Wikipedia says they closed in 1979 and 1985, and cleanup began in 2002 with a barrier, a cap, fresh soil and plantings. The first phase opened in July 2019. The highest point is 140 feet above sea level and offers views of the Empire State Building, Jamaica Bay and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. See the Shirley Chisholm State Park guide.

Floyd Bennett Field, Brooklyn

New York City’s first municipal airport was built on Barren Island and nearby islands, which were joined by filling channels with sand, according to Wikipedia. It was dedicated on June 26, 1930, and opened to commercial flights on May 23, 1931. The Navy took over in 1941 and left in 1970. The site joined Gateway National Recreation Area in 1972, and the park opened in 1974. Today the old runways and open grass attract birds, and the NYC Bird Alliance rates it among the best places in the city for winter owls. See the Floyd Bennett Field guide.

Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island

Not a landfill, but a reclaimed military site. Wikipedia traces fortifications on the hill to 1655 and says the Navy used it from 1979 until it closed in 1994. The National Park Service took over in 1995 as part of Gateway National Recreation Area, and the complex was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2022. See the Fort Wadsworth guide.

Governors Island, New York Harbor

The island is about 172 acres, and Wikipedia says about 103 acres of that is fill added in the early 1900s. It served as an Army post, then a Coast Guard base until 1996. The federal government sold the remaining land to the city and state in 2003, and the public first visited in 2005. The Hills, built from 2016, rise between 26 and 70 feet. Read the Governors Island winter guide.

Pelham Bay Park’s Orchard Beach

Even a beach can be built. Wikipedia reports that Orchard Beach officially opened on June 25, 1937 and that building it took about 4,000,000 cubic yards of sand. Landfill also joined Twin Island to the beach and to Rodman’s Neck, and Twin Island was restored in 1995 for $850,000. Hunter Island shrank from 215 acres to 166 acres when the beach was extended in the 1930s.

What these parks have in common

  • Open ground. Reclaimed sites are big and flat or gently hilled, so they work for walking and birding.
  • Controlled access. Parts remain closed during construction or for nesting. Always check the official site first.
  • Wind and weather. There is little shelter, so dress for the harbor.
  • Views. Several offer wide skyline views from the high points.

Visiting tips

Check hours before every trip, because several sites open on limited schedules. Bring water, since services can be sparse. If you are visiting in winter, dress for wind and plan to finish before dusk. Combine one reclaimed park with one traditional park to see the contrast, such as Freshkills Park with the Staten Island Greenbelt.

What nature brought back

Reclaimed ground has a habit of filling with life. Wikipedia reports more than 200 bird species at Freshkills Park, including the largest nesting colony of grasshopper sparrows in New York State. The draft master plan for the park envisions five parks in one. At Floyd Bennett Field, the NYC Bird Alliance describes grasslands where harriers and kestrels hunt and where Snowy Owls typically appear from January through early March. The NYPD still uses part of the field as a helicopter base, and one runway is reserved for radio-controlled aircraft, according to Wikipedia.

The pattern is worth noticing. Birds that need open ground use the capped mounds and old runways because those places look like the grasslands and dunes they prefer.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to walk on a former landfill?

The parks are built on capped and remediated ground, with barriers and fresh soil, according to Wikipedia’s account of the work at Shirley Chisholm State Park. Follow posted rules and stay on marked paths.

Which reclaimed park is easiest to reach without a car?

Governors Island, by ferry from Lower Manhattan, and Orchard Beach, in Pelham Bay Park, which has a 6 train station (check the MTA for the connecting bus). Freshkills, Shirley Chisholm State Park, Floyd Bennett Field and Fort Wadsworth have no subway station nearby, so check the MTA for bus routes.

Which is the largest?

Freshkills Park, at about 2,200 acres planned.