Greenwich Village evening walk: jazz, comedy and theatre

Five stages within a few blocks of each other: two jazz basements, a Beckett-era theater, a flagship jazz club and a comedy cellar. Here is how to plan one evening.

A few streets in Greenwich Village are packed with live stages. Within a short walk you can find a basement that has hosted jazz since 1935, a theater built inside a silo, a jazz club with a second set at 10:30 PM, and a comedy cellar where the host decides who comes next. The trick is not finding something to see. It is choosing a route that keeps you out of lines and lets you hear a full set, not three half ones.

The route in order

Start at the Christopher St-Sheridan Sq. station on the 1 train. Walk the streets toward Commerce, West 10th and Seventh Avenue South, then head south and east to West 3rd and MacDougal Streets. The stops below follow that order.

1. Cherry Lane Theatre, 38 Commerce Street

This is the earliest stop in the evening. The Cherry Lane Theatre began as a farm silo in 1817, according to Wikipedia, and it later opened as a theater. It has a 167-seat main stage and hosted the American premiere of Samuel Beckett’s Endgame in 1958. The two productions on its official site this season each run about one hour, so a Cherry Lane show can fit before a later set. Check each production’s age recommendation first.

2. Smalls, 183 West 10th Street

The official calendar for Smalls Jazz Club shows two evening sets, for example 6:00 and 7:30 PM, or 9:00 and 10:30 PM. The room is a basement that Wikipedia lists at a capacity of 74. Late-night jam sessions are listed from about 11:55 PM to 4:00 AM, which makes Smalls the last stop on a long night.

3. Village Vanguard, 178 Seventh Avenue South

The Village Vanguard opened on February 22, 1935, according to Wikipedia. It sits a short walk from Smalls. The club asks guests to silence phones and keep conversation low, so treat this stop as a listening session. Buy tickets from the artist listing on the official site, and check the set times on the night.

4. Blue Note, 131 West 3rd Street

The Blue Note opened on September 30, 1981. The page we checked listed an 8:00 PM show and a 10:30 PM second set. Brunch shows with gospel and soul acts are listed on weekends.

5. Comedy Cellar, 117 MacDougal Street

The Comedy Cellar is a short walk from the Blue Note. Shows use a showcase format of five to seven comics with sets of about 10 to 15 minutes, per Wikipedia. Its larger sister room, Village Underground, is at 130 West 3rd Street, on the same street as the Blue Note.

Three ways to build the night

You cannot see everything, and you should not try. Each club sells its own tickets and sets different times. Pick one of these plans and stop there.

  • The jazz double. An early set at Smalls (for example 6:00 PM), a walk to the Vanguard for a later set, and nothing else. Keep a gap of at least 30 minutes between shows.
  • The theater and comedy night. A one-hour Cherry Lane production, a short dinner, then a Comedy Cellar show. Comedy Cellar shows on weekends are listed from 6:45 PM into the night, so you can choose a later slot.
  • The big night out. Blue Note at 8:00 PM, then a late set or a jam at Smalls after 11:55 PM. This is the one to try only if you are comfortable with a late night.

What it costs and what to book

Prices change, so check each site on the day. A few numbers are stable enough to plan with. The Comedy Cellar’s official page lists a two-item minimum per person, which can be food, a drink or a bottle of water. It listed tickets at $25 on Friday and Saturday and lower prices on weeknights when we checked. The Village Vanguard sells tickets per artist, and Smalls sells through event pages. Book each show directly on the club’s own page. Do not buy from resellers.

Practical tips

  • Subway: The 1 train to Christopher St-Sheridan Sq. reaches the west end of the route. The A, B, C, D, E, F and M trains to West 4 St-Washington Sq. reach the east end.
  • Watch before you go. Smalls streams its evenings for free, and the club says the whole evening is streamed during normal hours. A few minutes of the stream shows you the room.
  • Phones. The Vanguard asks guests to silence phones. Treat that as a rule for every listening room.
  • Age rules. They differ by venue. Check each official page before bringing teenagers or children.
  • Weather. The walks between venues are outdoors and short, but streets are cold in winter. Wear a coat you do not mind carrying inside.

What to do around the edges

Leave a gap in the evening for Washington Square Park. It is close to the Blue Note and the Comedy Cellar, and it is an easy place to wait between sets. The Village is also full of small restaurants, so you can eat between shows. Book dinner early if you have a fixed set time.

Frequently asked questions

Can I see more than one show in one night?

Yes, if you plan the times. Smalls and the Village Vanguard are close together, and the Blue Note and Comedy Cellar are a short walk apart. Check each venue’s set times and leave a gap.

What is the cheapest way to start?

Watch the free Smalls livestream first. Then choose a weeknight Comedy Cellar show, which was listed at a lower price than weekend shows when we checked.

Which stop is best for a first-timer?

The Comedy Cellar and the Blue Note both have clear schedules and set times. The Vanguard and Smalls are best if you want a quiet listening room.