The word Off-Broadway confuses many first-time visitors. It does not mean a theater is far from Broadway, and it does not mean a show is less professional. It is a size category. Understanding that category is the fastest way to find a show that fits your evening, your budget and your taste, and to see work that often arrives on the big stages later.
What the label means
According to Wikipedia, Off-Broadway refers to professional New York City theaters with 100 to 499 seats. Off-Off-Broadway venues are smaller, with fewer than 100 seats. Broadway houses are larger. The label also depends on the union and other contracts that govern each production, so a few cases sit on the line.
Wikipedia also notes that the 499-seat cap was adopted in the 1970s, and that it lowered the minimum performer salaries required by Actors’ Equity. In practice, that means producers can afford to take chances on newer plays, small musicals and unusual ideas.
How the movement started
Off-Broadway grew in the 1950s as a less commercial alternative to Broadway. It gave work to new artists. Circle in the Square’s 1952 staging of Tennessee Williams’s Summer and Smoke was an early success. A 1954 revival of The Threepenny Opera showed that these productions could earn money, too, per Wikipedia.
Many famous shows began in these smaller houses. Wikipedia lists Hair, Rent and Hamilton among shows that premiered Off-Broadway before moving to Broadway. Others stayed small and ran for years. The Fantasticks played Off-Broadway from 1960 to 2002, and Blue Man Group and Stomp ran there without transferring.
Awards follow the same split. Off-Broadway work is eligible for the Obie, Drama Desk and Lucille Lortel awards, but generally not for the Tony Awards.
Places to start
You do not need a long list. These venues each show a different side of the scene.
- Cherry Lane Theatre. The Cherry Lane Theatre has a 167-seat main stage and a 60-seat studio, per Wikipedia. Its own site calls it New York’s oldest Off-Broadway theater, which is the theater’s claim. Beckett’s Endgame had its American premiere there in 1958.
- The Public Theater and Joe’s Pub. Joe’s Pub is one of six performance spaces in the Public Theater’s building at 425 Lafayette Street. It is named after Joseph Papp, who established the New York Shakespeare Festival and The Public.
- La MaMa. La MaMa operates at 74 East 4th Street and 66 East 4th Street, with spaces that include the Club, the Ellen Stewart Theatre and the Downstairs Theatre. Its official site says it is dedicated to the artist and all aspects of the theatre. The box office phone is (646) 430-5374, and its hours are 11 AM to 5 PM, Monday to Friday.
Many other houses fit the label. Check each venue’s own season page. Titles, dates and age ratings change from production to production.
How to buy tickets
Book from the theater’s own site first. The venue’s box office will show current prices and any fees. For a last-minute option, TKTS booths sell discounted tickets for same-day performances, and they list Off-Broadway shows alongside Broadway ones. On the day we checked, the TKTS page showed 11 Off-Broadway shows at Times Square and six at Lincoln Center. The page also warns that a few Off-Broadway shows are cash only. Our guide to discount theater tickets and TKTS explains the booths in detail.
What to expect from the evening
- Short runs. Some productions are an hour long. The Cherry Lane’s two productions listed this season each run about one hour.
- Small rooms. A 167-seat house such as the Cherry Lane puts the stage close to every seat.
- Different ratings. A show at the Cherry Lane was marked for ages 18 and up on its official site. Always read the age note before you bring younger guests.
- New work. Wikipedia describes the movement as a place for emerging artists, so the cast and writers may be new to you.
How to read a venue page before you book
Small theaters give you a lot of detail, so use it. Look for four things on the official page: the running time, the age recommendation, the date range and the ticket source. A one-hour show can sit comfortably before a late dinner. A show marked for adults only is not a good pick for a family outing. A short run may end within a few weeks, so a title that interests you today may not be there next month. Finally, buy from the link on the theater’s own site. That keeps your money with the company, and it keeps you away from look-alike resale pages.
It also helps to remember the scale of the long runs. The Fantasticks played Off-Broadway for 42 years, from 1960 to 2002. That is rare, though. Most Off-Broadway productions are short and focused, and the best way to catch one is to check the calendar a week or two ahead.
A simple plan
Choose a neighborhood. East Village and West Village rooms are within walking distance of one another and of jazz and comedy clubs, which gives you flexible choices. Book a show that runs 90 minutes or less if you want a late dinner. Use the official site to confirm the day and time of the performance before you travel.
Frequently asked questions
Is Off-Broadway cheaper than Broadway?
Often, but not always. Prices differ by show. Compare the venue’s own page with TKTS, which lists discounted same-day seats.
Can I see a Tony winner Off-Broadway?
Off-Broadway productions are generally not eligible for Tonys, according to Wikipedia. They are eligible for the Obie, Drama Desk and Lucille Lortel awards.
What is the difference between Off-Broadway and Off-Off-Broadway?
Seat count. Off-Broadway houses seat 100 to 499 people. Off-Off-Broadway venues seat fewer than 100.