Barney Greengrass
Barney Greengrass has called itself the Sturgeon King for decades, and the title was given to its founder in 1938, according to Wikipedia. The shop sells smoked fish, bagels and spreads from a counter on Amsterdam Avenue, and a plain dining room serves lunch and brunch. It is a daytime place. Come hungry, come before the afternoon, and order the fish.
At a glance
- Address: 541 Amsterdam Avenue, between 86th and 87th Streets, New York, NY 10024
- Nearest subway: 86th Street (1 at Broadway, or B and C at Central Park West)
- Hours: The official site lists the store as Tuesday to Sunday, 8 AM to 5 PM. The restaurant is Tuesday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 4 PM, and Saturday and Sunday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM. Check the official site for changes.
- Admission: Free to enter. Check the official site for current menu prices.
- Best for: Brunch, smoked fish, gifts
- Time needed: 45 to 90 minutes
- Official website: barneygreengrass.com
Why it is worth your time
Wikipedia says Barney Greengrass opened a restaurant in 1908 at West 113th Street and St. Nicholas Avenue, then moved to 86th Street and Amsterdam Avenue in 1929. His son Moe ran it afterward with his wife, and Moe’s son Gary took over after Moe died in 2001, according to the same source.
The shop has a long list of admirers. Wikipedia reports that it won a James Beard Foundation award in 2006 and that the Financial Times ranked it among the world’s 50 greatest food stores in 2021. It also records Anthony Bourdain writing that the chopped liver was the best there is.
What to see and do
- Order sturgeon. It is the shop’s signature fish, according to Wikipedia.
- Try nova. The official site shows nova as a featured product.
- Add whitefish salad. It also appears on the site.
- Taste the chopped liver. It is the dish Bourdain praised, per Wikipedia.
- Take home pastrami or caviar. The site lists both under shop categories.
Insider tips
- Closed Mondays unless a holiday notice says otherwise. The official site mentioned a Monday opening on one holiday only.
- Arrive early on weekends. Brunch lines form.
- Look at the dine-in menu PDF on the website before you go.
- Pair a visit with a walk in Riverside Park, a few blocks west.
- Buy fish at the counter to carry home. Ask how long it keeps.
Nearby
- Zabar’s, a few blocks south on Broadway.
- Riverside Park for a walk along the Hudson.
- Our Upper West Side appetizing guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is Barney Greengrass known for?
Smoked fish, especially sturgeon, according to Wikipedia. The shop also sells nova, whitefish and other deli items.
Is it open for dinner?
No, based on the hours the official site lists. It closes in the late afternoon.
Is it a restaurant or a store?
Both. The store and the restaurant have separate hours on the official site.

