City Island is part of the Bronx, yet it feels like a New England harbor town. It is about a mile and a half long, with a main street of seafood restaurants, boat yards and old houses. Getting there takes a subway and a bus, which is part of the charm.
Getting there
Take the 6 train to its last stop at Pelham Bay Park, then transfer to the Bx29 bus onto the island, according to the Seattle Times archive. Check the MTA for current service before you go. A car also works, but weekend traffic on the single bridge can be slow. Our Pelham Bay Park listing describes the park next door.
A seafaring past
City Island has a long maritime history. Its shipbuilding community peaked in the mid-1900s and is still part of the island today, according to Untapped New York. Native Americans lived on the island before European settlement and left shell middens from oysters and clams, according to a Wikipedia mirror. Burials in the island’s cemetery carry carvings of ships and sailboats, according to NYC Tourism.
Look for the boat yards and marinas as you walk. They show that this is still a working harbor.
The Nautical Museum
The City Island Nautical Museum is in the old PS 17 schoolhouse on Fordham Street. Forgotten New York says it displays maritime artifacts and exhibits on shipbuilders, fishermen and America’s Cup yachtsmen. One travel guide lists weekend hours and an $8 admission, but that information may be out of date, so confirm before you go.
Eating on City Island Avenue
The island is known for seafood, with lobster a popular dish. Restaurants line City Island Avenue, and sources count nearly 30 of them. Rather than recommend a single place, walk the street, read menus and pick a spot with a table you like. Prices vary widely, and waterfront tables often cost more.
Go for a late lunch to avoid the crowd, and bring cash for small purchases. Some places have limited hours in winter, so check before you commit to a long trip.
How to spend the day
- Arrive mid-morning and walk the length of City Island Avenue.
- Visit the Nautical Museum if it is open.
- Eat lunch.
- Walk the side streets to see old houses and the water.
- Return through Pelham Bay Park, or combine it with a walk there.
Because the island is small, you can see it on foot. Wear comfortable shoes and bring a jacket, since the wind off the water can be strong.
Seasonal notes
Summer weekends bring the biggest crowds and the most traffic. Spring and fall are calmer. Winter is quiet, with some shops and restaurants on reduced hours. A cold, clear winter day can be the best time to appreciate the harbor, but check that your lunch spot is open.
Accessibility
NYC Tourism publishes an accessibility guide for City Island, which is a good place to check before you plan. The bus route and the length of the main street are both useful details for visitors with mobility needs. Contact specific venues if you need information about steps or restrooms.
Combine it with a park day
Pelham Bay Park and City Island fit together. Spend the morning in the park, then take the bus to the island for lunch. Read our Bronx parks guide for other options.
For a food day that stays inland, see our Arthur Avenue plan.
What to look for as you walk
Walk slowly and look at the details that make the island distinct. Boat yards and marinas line the water, and small houses sit on narrow side streets. Signs and plaques sometimes explain the history. The main avenue is the best place to see the restaurants, shops and the rhythm of the place.
Because the island is narrow, you are never far from the water. Side streets often end at a view of the harbor, and these quiet corners are good places for a short rest.
Read the menus outside restaurants before you choose. Look for a place that fits your budget and has the dishes you want, and ask about wait times on busy days.
Planning tips
Check the MTA before you leave, since the Bx29 bus runs on its own schedule. Allow extra time for the return trip, especially on weekend evenings. Bring a charged phone, a payment card and some cash. In summer, bring sun protection. In winter, bring a warm hat and gloves, because the wind off the water is strong.
If you plan to visit the Nautical Museum, check its hours first, since small museums often keep limited schedules. If it is closed, the walk along the avenue and a meal still make a full outing.
Why go at all
Most New York visitors never leave Manhattan, and many New Yorkers never visit City Island. That is the reason it works. For the price of a subway and bus ride, you get a different pace, a harbor view and a meal by the water. It is a good reminder that the five boroughs hold very different places.
Before you go
Treat this as a casual outing rather than a checklist. Decide what matters most to you, whether that is lunch, the museum or a harbor walk, and let the rest fall into place.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get to City Island?
Take the 6 train to Pelham Bay Park, then the Bx29 bus.
How long is the island?
About a mile and a half, according to several sources.
What is City Island known for?
Seafood restaurants, boat yards and a maritime history.