The Village Vanguard is a basement reached by fifteen steps. The Blue Note has been a Greenwich Village jazz room since 1981. Smalls reopened in 2006 after a three-year closure. Together they sit within a short walk of one another, and together they show how jazz works in New York: small rooms, close seats and musicians who play for a few feet of audience. This guide explains how the three differ so you can pick the night that fits you.
The Village Vanguard
The Vanguard is at 178 Seventh Avenue South. Wikipedia gives the opening as February 22, 1935, and says its founder, Max Gordon, bought a former speakeasy called the Golden Triangle and renamed it. It began as a venue for poetry readings and folk music, with performers such as Lead Belly. Jazz became the main focus in 1957, according to the same source.
The club’s recording history is the strongest argument for going. Wikipedia lists live albums made there by Sonny Rollins in 1957, and John Coltrane and Bill Evans in 1961. Cecile McLorin Salvant’s Dreams and Daggers, a live album recorded at the Vanguard, won a Grammy in 2018 for best jazz vocal album.
Every Monday night the Vanguard Jazz Orchestra plays. The club’s own website says the band began in 1966 as the Thad Jones/Mel Lewis Orchestra, booked for three Mondays that February, and has since played more than 2,700 Monday nights. It is one of the longest-running residencies in jazz. The website also asks guests to silence phones and keep conversation low, which tells you what kind of room this is.
The family story is part of the draw. Wikipedia says Lorraine Gordon, Max’s wife, persuaded him in 1948 to book Thelonious Monk, whose opening week was poorly attended. Max Gordon died in 1989, and Lorraine ran the club until her death in 2018. For most of its life, then, the Vanguard has had a single family deciding who plays.
The Blue Note
The Blue Note is at 131 West 3rd Street. According to Wikipedia, it opened on September 30, 1981, with the Nat Adderley Quintet. Its founder, Danny Bensusan, believed that big acts in a comfortable room with good food would fill the club every night. Artists listed as playing there include Dizzy Gillespie, Sarah Vaughan and Chick Corea.
The Blue Note is built for a night out. It serves dinner, and its programming leans toward well-known names. It grew into a brand, opening Blue Note Tokyo in 1988 and later other locations, but the original on West 3rd Street remains the flagship.
Smalls
Smalls is at 183 West 10th Street. Wikipedia says Mitchell Borden opened it in 1994, and it became known for late-night sets, with music that sometimes ran until six in the morning. Borden closed it on May 31, 2003, citing declining attendance after the September 11 attacks, rising rents and a smoking ban. In early 2006 he reopened it with the musicians Michael Wilner and Lee Kostrinsky. They improved the sound and added a full bar.
After the 2006 reopening Smalls shifted to two or three sets a night, according to Wikipedia, with live streaming added in 2013. That means you can sample the room online before you go.
How to choose
- For history: The Village Vanguard. Go on a Monday for the orchestra.
- For a dinner night: The Blue Note, where food and shows go together.
- For a late set and a streaming preview: Smalls, which has a long history of late-night playing.
If you want to compare, plan an early set at one club and a late set at another. All three are in Greenwich Village and the West Village, and you can walk between them.
A sample night
Start with an early dinner in the neighborhood, then take a first set at the club that matches your mood. If you want a Monday night of big-band sound, the Vanguard Jazz Orchestra is the obvious choice. On other nights, check each club’s calendar for who is playing, since the lineup matters more than the room. Afterward, walk a few blocks through the Village streets before heading home. The three rooms are close enough that a second set at another club is realistic if you have the energy and a ticket.
Read about the music first if you can. A single live album by the artist you are about to hear makes the night better, and the Vanguard’s own history, with live recordings dating to the 1950s, gives you plenty to choose from.
Practical tips
- Book ahead. Check each club’s website for tickets. Prices and set times change, and the figures in older articles may be out of date.
- Arrive early. Seating is close, and early arrivals get better views.
- Respect the room. The Vanguard says to silence phones and keep conversation to a minimum.
- Bring ID. These are bars as well as music rooms.
- Check closures. Clubs sometimes close for short breaks. Look at each site before you travel.
Beyond jazz
If you want live music of a different kind, Cafe Wha? on MacDougal Street has a house band from Wednesday to Sunday. For literary history, the White Horse Tavern is nearby. Our Greenwich Village walk ties these stops together.
Each club also has its own listing: Village Vanguard, Blue Note and Smalls.
Frequently asked questions
Which jazz club is the oldest?
The Village Vanguard opened in 1935 according to Wikipedia, which is earlier than the Blue Note (1981) and Smalls (1994). Wikipedia does not call it the oldest. The club’s own site describes it as widely regarded as New York’s oldest jazz club.
Can I just show up?
Sometimes. Popular nights sell out, so check each club’s site.
Is jazz in New York expensive?
Prices vary by club and artist. Check each site for current cover charges and minimums.