Castle Garden to Ellis Island: following immigrant history

A route through New York’s immigration story, from the 1855 depot at Castle Clinton to Ellis Island, a Lower East Side tenement and an 1887 synagogue.

Millions of people arrived in New York with a bag, a name that clerks often spelled wrong and no idea where they would sleep. The city has kept several of the places they passed through. You can see them in a rough order of arrival: a round fort at the tip of Manhattan, an island in the harbor, then the tenement and synagogue where many families began their new lives. This guide links them with dates and practical notes.

Step 1: Castle Clinton, the first depot (1855 to 1890)

Castle Clinton sits in Battery Park. It was built from 1808 to 1811 as a fort, and it became Castle Garden, an entertainment venue, after the city leased it in 1824. From 1855 to 1890 it served as the first U.S. immigrant processing depot. Sources estimate that 7.5 to 8 million immigrants were processed there. Castle Garden closed in April 1890, when processing moved to Ellis Island, and the building was an aquarium from 1896 to 1941.

The National Park Service has run it since the 1950s. Today it is the ticket office and departure point for the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries. See our Castle Clinton guide.

Step 2: Ellis Island, the main station (1892 to 1954)

Ellis Island opened as an immigration station on January 1, 1892. Annie Moore, a 17-year-old from Ireland, was its first immigrant. A fire destroyed the wooden buildings in 1897, and the fireproof main building opened on December 17, 1900. About 12 million immigrants were processed between 1892 and 1954. The station closed on November 12, 1954.

The Registry Room, or Great Hall, is where inspectors carried out medical and legal checks. The museum opened on September 10, 1990, after a restoration. The island is reached only by ferry, and the National Park Service says some exhibits are temporarily closed and construction is underway. Read our Ellis Island guide and check the NPS page before you go.

Step 3: the tenement

Many immigrants settled in crowded Lower East Side buildings like 97 Orchard Street. It was built in 1863, during the Castle Garden years. Wikipedia estimates that about 15,000 people from over 20 nations lived in the two Orchard Street buildings used by the Tenement Museum. The landlord sealed the upper floors in 1935. The museum was founded in 1988 and offers guided tours only. See the Tenement Museum guide.

Step 4: the synagogue

The synagogue at 12 Eldridge Street was dedicated on September 4, 1887. The museum describes it as the first grand synagogue built by Eastern European Jewish immigrants in the United States. The main sanctuary was closed by 1954 after the Immigration Act of 1924 and the departure of members, and a restoration that cost about $20 million was rededicated on December 2, 2007. See our Museum at Eldridge Street guide.

How the places connect

The dates line up in a useful way. Castle Garden handled arrivals until 1890. Ellis Island opened in 1892. The Orchard Street tenement was built in 1863, while Castle Garden was in use, and its upper floors stayed in use until 1935. The Eldridge Street synagogue was dedicated in 1887, just before Ellis Island opened. The Immigration Act of 1924 appears in two places. It limited new arrivals and, according to Wikipedia, was one factor in the Eldridge Street congregation’s decline. Looking at all four makes it clear that the story of immigration in New York is a story of buildings as well as numbers.

What changed between the two stations

Castle Garden was a converted fort that had been a theater, and the move to Ellis Island gave the country a purpose-built station. The island itself was reshaped for the job: the NPS says it grew from a couple of acres to over 30 to make room for a processing station and a hospital complex. After 1924, the station mainly held people awaiting detention or deportation, and it served as a military detention site in both World Wars, according to Wikipedia. Its closure in 1954 ended an era that had begun at Castle Garden almost a century earlier.

The fort had its own close call. In 1941 Robert Moses proposed demolishing it as part of the rebuilding of Battery Park for the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel. Preservation efforts continued, and the fort became a national monument in 1946. Without that outcome, the place where millions first set foot in the country would be missing from today’s route.

How to plan the day

  1. Morning: start at Castle Clinton and take the ferry to Ellis Island. Allow half a day for the island.
  2. Afternoon or another day: take the subway to the Lower East Side for the Tenement Museum or the Museum at Eldridge Street.

Do not try to see all four in a single day unless you start very early. The island trip alone takes much of a day. Book tours in advance where possible, and check each official site for hours, since the Eldridge Street museum is closed on Saturdays.

Practical tips

  • Tickets: The NPS names statuecruises.com for advance ferry tickets. Confirm on the NPS site.
  • Security: Ferry visitors pass airport-style security. Knives, multi-tools, mace, scooters, skateboards and musical instruments are prohibited, per the NPS.
  • Weather: The ferry is partly outdoors, so dress for the harbor.
  • Accessibility: Some Tenement Museum tours involve stairs. Ask the museum.

Frequently asked questions

What came before Ellis Island?

Castle Garden, in Battery Park, served as the immigrant depot from 1855 to 1890.

How many people passed through Ellis Island?

About 12 million between 1892 and 1954.

Can I visit Castle Clinton and Ellis Island on the same trip?

Yes. Castle Clinton is the ferry departure point, so a stop there before the ferry is easy.