Coney Island sells itself on sensation, but its real draw is the layers of history. The Cyclone has been running since 1927, the Wonder Wheel since 1920 and Nathan’s hot dog stand since 1916. This guide sets out those dates, what each place means, and where to go when you want the story behind the screams. Dates come from published sources, noted below.
The Cyclone: 1927
According to published histories, the Cyclone opened to the public on June 26, 1927, on a site at Luna Park. It was designated a New York City landmark on July 12, 1988, and listed on the National Register of Historic Places on June 26, 1991. A historical marker entry describes it as 2,640 feet long and 85 feet high. Sources disagree on the construction cost, with figures of $100,000 and $175,000 appearing, so treat the number as uncertain.
Ride schedules are seasonal, so check the operator’s current calendar before you travel in winter.
The Wonder Wheel: 1920
CBS News says the Wonder Wheel opened on Memorial Day in 1920. VOA News says it has been family-owned and operated since it opened. One outlier source gives 1918, so most outlets use 1920.
As with the Cyclone, check the operator’s calendar before planning around a ride in the cold months.
Nathan’s Famous: 1916
Nathan Handwerker founded the stand in 1916 after emigrating from Poland in 1912, according to published histories. He had worked for Feltman’s, an earlier Coney Island hot dog business. The stand’s July 4 hot dog eating contest is also linked to its history, and one source ties the first contest to 1916.
The earlier days
Coney Island’s first American roller coaster opened on June 16, 1884, according to a Fox News history item. Parts of the original Luna Park burned in 1944, and it officially closed in 1946, according to Business Insider. The park that exists today carries on the name.
These dates show how often the amusement district rebuilt itself: new rides, fires, closures and returns.
Where to learn the story
The Coney Island Museum is at 1208 Surf Avenue in a building from 1917. In October 2025 the museum and Coney Island USA unveiled a plaque marking its landmark status. The museum’s blog covers subjects such as the 1905 Igorot village at Luna Park and Weegee’s photographs of Coney Island in the 1940s.
Admission is $5 for adults and $3 for seniors, children under 12 and residents of ZIP code 11224, with tickets sold at the gift shop only. The museum is on the second floor and is not wheelchair accessible at this time. Hours listed are for May to September, so check the official site for winter.
Planning your trip
The D, Q, N and F trains stop at Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue, and the museum is nearby on Surf Avenue.
In November many rides and stands are closed or reduced. The museum and some businesses run on their own schedules. Treat the trip as a walk and a history stop, then check the calendar of Coney Island USA for any events.
For a different Brooklyn waterfront the same day, consider Brooklyn Bridge Park, though it is a long ride from Coney Island.
A short reading list
- The museum’s blog for stories from Luna Park.
- The Landmarks Preservation Commission for the Cyclone’s designation.
- The Coney Island USA events page for current programs.
How to read the dates
Local history is full of competing numbers, and Coney Island is a good example. The Wonder Wheel is reported as opening in 1920 by most outlets and as 1918 by one. The Cyclone’s cost appears as $100,000 in one source and $175,000 in others. The simple rule is to prefer official designation records, such as the landmark date of July 12, 1988, over round numbers in popular articles.
When you read a sign or a plaque on site, notice what it claims and what it leaves out. The Coney Island Museum is useful here because it frames its building as part of a longer story, from the 1905 Luna Park exhibits to the landmark plaque unveiled on October 11, 2025.
A good order for a day trip
- Arrive at Stillwell Avenue and walk to Surf Avenue.
- Visit the museum first, if it is open, so you know what you are looking at.
- Walk the boardwalk and look at the Cyclone and Wonder Wheel from the outside.
- Eat at a long-standing stand, after checking its hours.
- Finish with an event at Coney Island USA if one is listed.
Starting with the museum helps. By the time you reach the rides, the dates and names have context, and the old photographs are easier to compare with what you see.
Why the history matters
Coney Island was a place where entertainment, food and public life met on a very large scale. Nathan’s began as a small stand in 1916, the Wonder Wheel is still family-owned according to VOA News, and the Cyclone is a protected landmark. Each survives because people kept choosing to go.
That is the best reason to visit in the off-season. Without the crowds you can see the buildings, hear the sea and appreciate how much of a resort is built on memory.
Frequently asked questions
When did the Cyclone open?
June 26, 1927, according to published histories.
Is the Coney Island Museum open in winter?
The visit page lists May to September hours. Check the official site for off-season hours.
How do I get to Coney Island?
Take the D, Q, N or F train to Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue.